Who could top the March 1st column written by Sun Media’s Christina Blizzard as she writes of George Smitherman’s antics…
See original article here.
Smitherman’s Silly Stunt
By: Christina Blizzard
TORONTO — Health Minister George Smitherman must surely be one of the most high profile and kamikaze examples of arrested development I have ever seen.
Look at his history of public confessions of things that are best left private: First there was a front-page picture of him weeping over the plight of abused people in long-term care facilities.
Then in 2006, he admitted to using “party drugs” at a time he was under stress because his father had been incapacitated by a stroke.
Last year, the openly gay minister mused in a scrum that he was considering wearing a thong to his wedding. And he’s forever agonizing publicly about his weight. Talk about insecurity!
This week, the one-time Liberal attack dog left reporters scratching their heads after he announced that as “a matter of conscience,” he has “seriously been considering” personally testing a new type of adult diaper.
Hello? Earth to George. Too much information.
If anyone else in cabinet displayed that kind of erratic behaviour, there would be speculation that he was, well, a tad overwrought emotionally and that maybe he should take a break from his work to pull himself together.
New Democratic Leader Howard Hampton called for Smitherman’s resignation. PC Leader John Tory said he should apologize.
“This was the man, you will recall, who tearfully promised to bring about a revolution in long-term care,” Tory said at a news conference yesterday. “His idea of a revolution is to put on some sort of a sideshow where he says he will try out some kind of an adult diaper.”
Sadly, though, the real problem in all of this has become lost in Smitherman’s weird antics.
The issue that we should be addressing is how much personal care elderly — and often helpless — people in long-term care facilities receive. The new diaper in question is controversial. It is super absorbent — so old people can sit around longer in their own waste before a care worker needs to go clean them up.
Unions came here this week to ask for a minimum of 3.5 hours of personal care for seniors. They poured four jugs of water into the diaper to show just how much liquid it would take before a coloured band indicated it needed changing.
That’s what is so shocking about Smitherman’s silly stunt. His off-the-cuff remark is demeaning and insulting. While he claims to have been personally touched by his father’s illness, you wonder if all the drugs he was doing at that time desensitized him to the suffering of other elderly people.
If it were your mother, your father or your grandparents sitting for hours and hours in a sodden diaper, how would you feel hearing that the health minister has trivialized it by joking he’s going to wear one? Yesterday, Smitherman put out a mealy-mouthed written statement saying, “If people were offended, or think I shouldn’t have raised those comments, I do apologize.”
Well, George, it’s not a question of “if” we’re offended. It’s more a question of how deeply insulted we are by these callous remarks.
His boss, Premier Dalton McGuinty, was even worse. Asked about Smitherman’s gaffe, McGuinty stood by his man.
“I know that it is easy to go and make fun of this particular issue, but it is really one about human dignity and we should keep it in mind,” McGuinty said. That’s not good enough.
There are times when a premier needs to come out and say that his minister has erred, that it is unacceptable, and that minister will apologize. Or he’ll be hauled onto the carpet — and forced to quit.
// 